Full text
| |
| Author(s): |
Fábio de Andrade Machado
Total Authors: 1
|
| Document type: | Doctoral Thesis |
| Press: | São Paulo. |
| Institution: | Universidade de São Paulo (USP). Instituto de Biociências (IBIOC/SB) |
| Defense date: | 2017-02-21 |
| Examining board members: |
Gabriel Henrique Marroig Zambonato;
José Alexandre Felizola Diniz Filho;
Tiana Kohlsdorf;
Paulo Inácio de Knegt López de Prado
|
| Advisor: | Gabriel Henrique Marroig Zambonato |
| Abstract | |
The phenotype of complex characters is the end-product of the interrelations between genes, ontogenetic pathways and environmental effects. The variation in these factors influences not only the final phenotype, but also how characters covary and evolve in an integrated way. Natural selection can influence the interaction among characters, leading to changes in the patterns of integration. Therefore, a integrative and dynamic view of complex phenotypes is essential to the understanding of the evolutionary history of such structures. In the present thesis I investigated the morphological integration of cranial characters in Caniform species in two perspectives. In the first approach I investigated the pattern of morphological integration of the species through the comparison of character variances and covariances. The results of this investigation highlighted two points. The first is that there is considerable stability in the covariance among characters along the evolutionary history of Carnivora, suggesting the maintenance of ontogenetic pathways in the group. The second is that, despite this stability, Canidae species show changes in their morphological integration that make them more similar among each other and more different from the rest of Carnivora. These changes are related mainly to characters from the facial region, which showed a greater evolutionary flexibility, greater correlation among characters, and concentrate a greater proportion of the variance in Canidae than in the rest of Carnivora. In a second approach I evaluated the statistical properties of tests based on quantitative genetics theory: the test of regression of eigenvalues and the test of correlation of principal components (PCs). These tests investigate the proportionality between patterns of genetic and between-species covariance as a way to test the null hypothesis of genetic drift. The results show that the use of phylogenetic independent contrasts (PIC) reduces the inflated type I error, especially in the case of the correlation test. When PIC are employed, the correlation test shows nominal type I error rates for all species sample sizes. However, the oscillation of the effective population size (Ne) inflates type I error rates of these tests. The regression test, despite showing inadequate type I error rates at small species sample sizes, is robust to the oscillation of Ne. The reduction of the number of PCs reduces type I error rates to nominal values at the expense of statistical power. The power of both tests is similar under different scenarios evaluated, with a slight tendency of the correlation test to perform better at small number of species. Additionally, the Caniform families were used as case studies for both tests. Tests were performed using parametric and non-parametric (simulations) techniques, with and without PIC. The drift hypothesis was rejected for almost all families, with the exception of Mephitidae and Ursidae. The regression tests based on simulations were consistent with and without the use of PIC, showing narrower confidence intervals than the ones for parametric tests. The results of the present thesis open a wide range of future investigation opportunities, both from the empirical (relative to the differences in Canidae patterns of morphological integration or the evolutionary processes underlying Ursidae and Mephitidae diversification) and methodological (further investigations of the properties of the quantitative genetics-based tests for macroevolution) points of view (AU) | |
| FAPESP's process: | 11/21674-4 - Evolutionary consequences of morphological integration in the skull and mandible of Caniformia (Carnivora; Mammalia) |
| Grantee: | Fábio de Andrade Machado |
| Support Opportunities: | Scholarships in Brazil - Doctorate |