Sensitivity analysis of indicator weights for the construction of flood vulnerability indexes: A participatory approach

Author(s)

Moreira, Luana Lavagnoli ; Vanelli, Franciele Maria ; Schwamback, Dimaghi ; Kobiyama, Masato ; de Brito, Mariana Madruga

• Document type: Journal article
• Source: FRONTIERS IN WATER; v. 5, p. 12-pg., 2023-02-06.

Abstract

The assessment of flood vulnerability is a complex task that involves numerous uncertainties. Within this context, sensitivity analyses are crucial to better understand the variability of vulnerability index outcomes according to different input parameters. The present study sheds light on the importance of assessing the sensitivity of different criteria weights to construct flood vulnerability indexes using the Maquine basin (Brazil) as a case study. Specifically, we compared vulnerability scores based on weights derived from a participatory survey with 44 stakeholders to those based on an equal weighting scheme. Results helped us identify areas with low and high uncertainty and the variables contributing to this. Overall, the preference for indicator weights did not vary significantly among stakeholders with distinct socioeconomic characteristics. Furthermore, the choice of weights only had an impact on the spatial distribution of flood vulnerability in certain regions. Compared to equal weights, the flood vulnerability outcomes obtained by averaging the stakeholder scenarios were similar, indicating that the results were robust and not highly sensitive to the choice of weights. By adopting a participatory approach, we were able to consider multiple stakeholders' views, which helped to provide a more comprehensive perspective of flood vulnerability and potentially increased the acceptance of the results. Based on our findings, end-users can better understand the relative importance of each indicator and how they contribute to vulnerability. Furthermore, our results can help identify points where stakeholders disagree, which can be used to facilitate dialogue and consensus building. The methodology applied is straightforward and could be easily adapted to other multi-criteria decision-making problems. (AU)

• FAPESP's process: 19/24292-7 - Infiltration and runoff dynamics under different land uses and climate change in the Brazilian Cerrado area
• Grantee: Dimaghi Schwamback
• Support Opportunities: Scholarships in Brazil - Doctorate
• FAPESP's process: 21/14016-2 - Hydrus model for the theoretical representation of vertical flow under different land uses commonly found in the Brazilian Cerrado biome
• Grantee: Dimaghi Schwamback
• Support Opportunities: Scholarships abroad - Research Internship - Doctorate