Advanced search
Start date
Betweenand

The transition from the Doctrine of Being to the Doctrine of Essence

Grant number: 19/21811-3
Support type:Scholarships abroad - Research Internship - Scientific Initiation
Effective date (Start): December 15, 2019
Effective date (End): March 14, 2020
Field of knowledge:Humanities - Philosophy
Principal researcher:Marcos Severino Nobre
Grantee:Dalmiro Schwartz Lara
Supervisor abroad: Christoph Asmuth
Home Institution: Instituto de Filosofia e Ciências Humanas (IFCH). Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP). Campinas , SP, Brazil
Research place: Technical University of Berlin (TU), Germany  
Associated to the scholarship:18/05655-9 - The circularity of Hegel's logic and the problem of the beginning, BP.IC

Abstract

This research aims to analyze the transition from the first book of Hegel's Science of Logic (The Doctrine of Being) to the second one (The Doctrine of Essence). One of the guidelines of this project is the thesis from Dieter Henrich, exposed in his article Hegels Logik der Reflexion. There Henrich defends that Being emerges from Essence, and that this relation of retrospective implication between these two doctrines of the Logic is shown in the last chapter of The Doctrine of Being, since the resolution of the category of Indifference can only be fully understood through the light of the first categories of the second book. Since there are many commentators with different positions about that topic (one of them is McTaggart, who believes there should be a direct transition from Indifference to Identity, and who's position is directly questioned by Henrich), we intend to confront some of them with Hegel's texts so that we can formulate a position about which one of them seems to be more consistent. (AU)